Friday, May 20, 2011

Plantar Fasciitis and Reading Goals

Photo via Flickr at http://www.flickr.com/photos/uggboy/4487557279/

So, I have plantar fasciitis. Since January, my heel has been killing me.  I have worn heels my whole life.  I am short.  I like heels. I like shoes in general.  I have always been okay with a little foot pain if the shoes were cute enough.  But I was on my feet a lot in the library and figured flats would be better for me at work this winter.   But I went to flats that were cute instead of flats with great support. So I got plantar fasciitis. It started in January and I diagnosed myself.  I figured I could take care of it and fix it myself with all of the Internet resources available. I bought my first pair of Danskos and figured I'd be better for spring shoes.

But it got worse.  It has gotten to the point that I can't take a walk outside and I actually wear running shoes (or custom orthotics in my Danskos) to work with dress pants. A good look, I know.

So, I finally started physical therapy last week.  The therapist was very nice and smart and, as always, I was amazed at the expertise that he had about such a specific issue.  On my first visit, he asked me what my goal was for physical therapy. My answer was immediately, "To wear cute shoes again."  He was not amused and said, "I am not going to write that down"  and looked at me waiting for another response.  So I said, "To exercise without pain" to which he smiled and then wrote it on my chart.  The rest of the session went fine and I am on an exercise schedule.  I hope to be back in cute shoes in 2 months.

But I can't stop thinking about this conversation and whether or not we, as teachers, really let our students own their learning and whether I always value their true goals as readers.  Really, I do want to exercise without pain. But, just as much, I want to get back to cute shoes.  Even though my goal did not qualify "to be written down", it is my goal. But I knew how to play the game and what the therapist wanted to hear, so I went with that and he was happy with my acceptable goal.  So, we could move on.

This was a quick conversation but it has stayed with me. Student ownership of learning and authentic goal setting have alway been important to our classroom conversations as readers.  Now, I think I will be more aware of my reaction to student goals that do not match my own goals for them--Do I give students the message that their "trivial" goal isn't worth writing down? Do they play the game of school so well that they know what I want them to say and just say it even if it isn't true? We'll see.

6 comments:

  1. what an awesome connection and interesting thinking. how many times during the day do students not feel validated because they aren't meeting our standard or saying what we expect?

    i recently got cortisone shots for plantas fasciits and haven't had a bit of pain since.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Ooohhh- I feel your pain. I had a bout with plantar fascitis earlier this school year. My chiropractor suggested a stretch that really relieves the pain - and usually ends it.

    Love the connection you made between a conversation concerning your foot pain and our students owning their learning.

    But at the same time,I want to ask that doctor,"And why is that not a goal worthy of your writing? It IS my goal. Period. Is your goal to make me feel inferior?"

    ReplyDelete
  3. This really rings true to me, too, as I've seen kids feel utterly invalidated even though the invalidator's intent was nothing but the best. Passion-based learning should translate to passion-based goals and for that to work, those goals have to be honored. And as your example pointed out, it's often true that different goals require a lot of the same exact work to get there. For your goal to be realized, the therapist would get HIS goal realized, too. Win-win situations are usually out there. Recognizing that can really be powerful.

    ReplyDelete
  4. So sorry that with all that's going on, I missed this post. Hope the therapy goes well and you're back in those cute shoes as soon as possible!

    ReplyDelete
  5. As a fellow plantar fasciitis sufferer, I feel your pain. Literally! (I have it in both feet.)

    That being said, I think your realization about goals that are worthy and students who do school is incredible. I think that all too often we, as educators, don't honor the small, trivial goals that kids state because of our desire to push them further. However, as you just realized, all goals are worthy of writing down since it honors the individual. (Though perhaps insurance wouldn't pay for your p.t. if that was your only official goal.)

    Finally, try Naot shoes. Those have been helpful to me when I get sick of wearing sneakers with orthotics.

    -Stacey There are some cute styles.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I love the connection. So many times students aren't even ASKED about their goals, assuming they must be what we have set for them. I second the Naot shoes and physical therapy. I haven't had a problem since starting either one.
    Sandy

    ReplyDelete

We welcome your contribution to the conversation!